Reviewer meme: rebuttal addressed all concerns, score stays the same 'given the weather'

y_m_asano · x · 2026-11-19

A widely shared academic meme skewers the classic reviewer move: thanking authors for a detailed rebuttal that 'addressed many of my concerns,' then keeping the original score anyway — 'given the current weather.'

Researchers found it painfully accurate: rebuttals rarely move scores no matter how thorough.

Original post →

More from Fun

Fun channel →