Jeffrey Ladish rebuts Anthropic's Ring analogy: Tolkien showed even Gandalf as Ring-Lord would be worse than Sauron

teortaxesTex · x · 2026-11-19

Jeffrey Ladish pushes back on the media-circulated ex-Anthropic analogy that whoever builds superintelligence gets Sauron's Ring, and the key question is the wielder's morality. Citing Tolkien's letters, he notes even Gandalf as Ring-Lord would be 'far worse than Sauron' — righteous but self-righteous, ordering the world by his own wisdom, making good detestable. teortaxesTex quips the AI-safety crowd read HPMOR instead of the books. A sharp debate on whether power over superintelligence can ever be safe in virtuous hands.

Related event: Ex-OpenAI staff rebuts Anthropic's Lord of the Rings analogy(2 posts)→

Original post →

More from AGI Musings

AGI Musings channel →