Gary Marcus makes the bear case against Anthropic's IPO: revenue already off the exponential
GaryMarcus · x · 2026-11-19
Gary Marcus published a paid Substack essay arguing Anthropic's IPO may be a bad bet for investors and society:
- The bull case: best-in-class models plus exponential revenue growth, as in Brad Gerstner's October charts
- "Trillion-pound baby fallacy": exponentials rarely last. Recent data shows Anthropic has fallen off Q2's revenue rocket — a quarter that peaked during "tokenmaxxing" before Chinese models caught up and users gained alternatives
- Marcus argues actual revenue bars already trail the trajectory needed for a sustainable gargantuan business, concluding "Anthropic probably won't make it"
- He pairs the financial argument with a moral appeal not to buy the stock, while self-deprecatingly noting his earlier "peak bubble" Oracle call (made above $300; it now trades around $115)
Related event: Gary Marcus Systematically Challenges Anthropic's $1.4 Trillion Valuation(9 posts)→
More from Venture
- Chamath's megacorp thesis and Soren Larson's case that labs will become conglomerates — ericwdolan · 2026-11-22
- AGI believers drastically underestimated the equities wipeout, and now a credit crisis — teortaxesTex · 2026-11-21
- VC debate: the AI downturn is 'fake' and a wealth transfer to SF's AGI believers, not a bubble — jamestagg · 2026-11-21
- Chart: TSMC revenue up 1807% since 2005, no 'cyclical' slowdown in sight — BenBajarin · 2026-11-21
- Founder-led content took Stan to $27M ARR with $0 on ads — VibeMarketer_ · 2026-11-21
- Analysts clash over Nvidia: huge demand vs. Chamath's claim its over-earning era may be over — BenBajarin · 2026-11-21