Jeff Ladish: Tolkien would have strongly opposed using his work to justify chasing ASI

JeffLadish · x · 2026-11-19

AI safety researcher Jeff Ladish notes that people keep invoking Tolkien to argue for pursuing ASI, even though Tolkien himself would almost certainly have been strongly opposed.

He clarifies he's not claiming a metaphor should carry the argument — he's just surprised at the misreading — and links to Scott Alexander's "Against SURA" post on LessWrong for readers to judge the arguments directly. The exchange is another round in the ongoing debate over whether humanity should race toward superintelligence.

Original post →

More from AGI Musings

AGI Musings channel →