The handover debate: pro-AI arguments work by re-carving tribal boundaries, not reason

FioraStarlight · x · 2026-11-19

FioraStarlight argues the best rhetoric for advocating "handover" of power to AI is re-carving tribal boundaries rather than appeals to benefit: "You were already disempowered by the government, which is less aligned to you than a benevolent ASI. It's not humans vs. AIs — it's a choice between two superintelligences, one of which you have a better shot at aligning."

1a3orn agrees with the framing but notes it often fails because people intuit AI as a nitpicking scold loyal to Anthropic/OpenAI, so they can't emotionally accept an actually omnibenevolent superintelligence; it may require loyalty to a not-Anthropic AI as a prior principle. The exchange leans on Haidt-style moral foundations: pro-handover rests on "making the world best for everyone," while opposition rests on freedom, loyalty, and sanctity — a substantive alignment-community debate on the handover question.

Related event: Debate Erupts Over Whether Humanity Should Hand Power to AI(5 posts)→

Original post →