ICLR reviewer demands empirical evidence of information-theoretic lower bounds, author laments

AmartyaSanyal · x · 2026-11-19

Amartya Sanyal vents about peer review: an ICLR reviewer asked for empirical evidence of information-theoretic lower bounds — effectively requiring enumerating all programs. He jokes he'll need to start ICML experiments early, highlighting the mismatch between theory work and empirical demands in top-venue reviewing.

Original post →