How Much Inbox Access Should an Agent Get? Debating Fine-Grained Scopes

yenkel · x · 2026-11-19

A technical thread on permission granularity for AI agents touching user data. @yenkel argues the email API shouldn't treat "all emails" as the only scope: if a user asks to read one email, you shouldn't issue credentials that can read every email. Broad requests like "summarize my inbox" can stay broad, but APIs need finer-grained scopes.

@NattyChadwick asks whether the request sets the scope and policy decides issuance, and how a request whose scope is inherently every email gets narrowed — by time window or purely by policy. @yenkel replies that anything the API doesn't support needs a proxy policy layer.

Related event: How Much Inbox Access Should an Agent Get? Debating Fine-Grained Scopes(2 posts)→

Original post →

More from coding & agent

coding & agent channel →