ICLR 2027 Data: Only 9% of Papers Changed Scores in Rebuttal, Ups Beat Downs 12-to-1
CSProfKGD · x · 2026-11-19
Jueun Kim tracked score movement across 40k ICLR 2027 papers using live OpenReview data (Nov 6–16):
- Only 9% of papers changed score, with ups beating downs 12 to 1
- 64% of all changes were 2→3; a 1→4 jump happened just 4 times
- Papers starting at 2.5–2.75 moved up most (13–19%); papers at 1.0 rose only 0.3% of the time
- 1 in 4 papers that started at 1.0 has withdrawn, suggesting low-scored authors mostly pull out rather than fight
She also built a public rebuttal tracker where authors can enter their initial scores and compare against similar papers. Data comes from the OpenReview API; only counts are published, no review text or paper titles.
More from Research
- MIT CSAIL paper: frozen LLM agents design their own self-improvement without being told how — omarsar0 · 2026-11-19
- Radiology benchmark RadLE is 100% human-verified; RadLE 2.1 results coming at RSNA — DrDatta_AIIMS · 2026-11-19
- Anthropic Says Claude Solved Two Open Problems in Black Hole Physics — ghumare64 · 2026-11-19
- Shu Ding's essay 'Metaphors': protocols, dimensional analysis, and Curry-Howard — shuding · 2026-11-19
- Why your fine-tuning job takes longer than the FLOPs say — Hugging Face Blog · 2026-11-19
- CyberArena benchmark: Lithos defense agent wins 3-0, blocking 12 of 12 attacks — JiaZhihao · 2026-11-19