ICLR authors flag reviewer pattern: reject papers over demands never made in first review
HildeKuehne · x · 2026-11-19
MIT researcher Hilde Kuehne describes a recurring ICLR review pattern (seen in 3 cases): a reviewer asks for extra experiments in round one, then rejects the paper citing benchmarks or metrics that were never requested. In another case, a paper was rejected post-rebuttal by a single reviewer over "substantial grammatical errors" with zero examples — an issue no other reviewer raised. She urges authors to check for this pattern before the final response deadline.
More from Research
- PhD thesis explores intra-turn interaction beyond turn-based AI interfaces — round · 2026-11-19
- PhD thesis explores intra-turn interaction beyond turn-based AI interfaces — moonsandhues · 2026-11-19
- NeurIPS paper: diffusion models interpolate well but rarely extrapolate skills — liuzhuang1234 · 2026-11-19
- Norm-swap experiments trace Muon early-decay gains to weight norms — ziv_ravid · 2026-11-19
- Caveats: single-seed results, no clear win at 405M-1.4B evals — ziv_ravid · 2026-11-19
- Decay schedule tuned at 162M transfers to 1.4B, overtaking no-decay at 73% — ziv_ravid · 2026-11-19