Rodney Brooks, Roomba creator, calls today's humanoids learning dexterity 'pure fantasy'
lukas_m_ziegler · x · 2026-11-18
A profile-thread of robotics legend Rodney Brooks and his contrarian stance:
- Reactive over planning: In the 1980s he rejected the mainstream "model the world, plan, then act" paradigm, arguing "the world is its own best model" and stacking simple behaviors — later leading MIT's AI Lab/CSAIL for a decade.
- Roomba lineage: Co-founded iRobot, putting a bug-brain into a vacuum; later co-founded Rethink Robotics (failed) and Robust AI.
- 32-year accountability streak: Since 2018 he publishes dated predictions on self-driving, robots, AI and space travel, grading himself every January 1 until 2050.
- Anti-humanoid realism: Amid billions pouring into humanoids and Musk's $30-trillion Optimus claim, his essay "Why Today's Humanoids Won't Learn Dexterity" argues robot hands have tried grasping since 1961, human videos won't teach touch, and plug-and-play humanoids within decades are "pure fantasy thinking." His company ships wheeled warehouse robots that actually work.
NYT dubbed him "Godfather of Modern Robotics Says the Field Has Lost Its Way."
More from AGI Musings
- Tim Sweeney on AI job fears: same teleprompter script as the tractor panic 120 years ago — liu_mingyu · 2026-11-18
- LeCun signs open letter from 59 European leaders urging EU not to sleep through AI revolution — ylecun · 2026-11-18
- Dev observes that lying to LLMs works — and it's making people habitual liars — andimarafioti · 2026-11-18
- 20% of UK's Milburn Review report was AI-generated, sparking disclosure debate — birchlse · 2026-11-18
- 'Human' named Cambridge Dictionary's Word of the Year 2026 — shauntrennery · 2026-11-18
- Cambridge Dictionary picks 'Human' as Word of the Year 2026 — DeepLogin · 2026-11-18