Mathematician Michael Goldman: trusts LLM reviews over human peer review
skdh · x · 2026-11-18
Mathematician Michael Goldman published a provocative piece titled "Do We Still Need Math Journals?" — his answer is no. He says he now trusts LLM-based reviewing more than human peer review, including his own.
He also ran the numbers: French public research spends about €78M per year on journal subscriptions, half of it going to Elsevier — enough to give every one of France's 100-200k researchers a basic LLM subscription with €20M left over.
With dissemination covered by arXiv, quality control by AI, and selection by informal peer discussion (while formal publication takes over a year), journals' only remaining function is counting papers for hiring and promotion — a €78M/year system whose final output is a KPI.
More from AGI Musings
- Computer use is the best lens for LLM robotics: from coordinates to intuition — Scobleizer · 2026-11-18
- If AI automates engineering and research, moats shift to data, compute and capital — burny_tech · 2026-11-18
- Cyber consensus: exploits now land 7 days before patches, no end in sight — alliekmiller · 2026-11-18
- Gary Marcus shares 'famous last words' table of Enron, Lehman, SVB, FTX CEOs to mock AI hype — GaryMarcus · 2026-11-18
- A 26-Patent Inventor Asks: Can Curiosity Be Taught in the AGI Era? — tctjr · 2026-11-18
- AI equity researcher Chinasa Okolo named a Gates Foundation Goalkeepers leader — ChinasaTOkolo · 2026-11-18