jessi_cata on cosmic Darwinism, singletons, and why effective agents might not need a singleton

jessi_cata · x · 2026-11-18

AI alignment discussant jessicata lays out a framework on effectiveness vs. consumption of terminal goals: some means are more effective at replication or convergent instrumental goals, and one can imagine a state of nature with many effective agents where the more effective wins resource conflicts — an alternative to Bostrom's singleton that performs cosmic (eu/dys)genics to preserve room for "hobbyist" fun over pure productivity.

The thread traces a lineage from Friendly AI → AI safety → anti-successionism → anti-handoverism, and an intention to preserve multipolarity: the author doesn't especially like singletons and is fairly okay with cosmic Darwinism, noting it's quite different from what Friendly AI was supposed to be.

Original post →

More from AGI Musings

AGI Musings channel →