Researcher argues memorization isn't inherently bad; Jacobian method could test LLM reasoning

proteinrosh · x · 2026-11-18

proteinrosh makes a counterintuitive point: if structure prediction isn't the goal, memorization may not be bad — language and reasoning can extract information from representations in a fundamentally different way, so having sequences memorized isn't de facto harmful.

He also proposes a validation path: though expensive, @sokrypton's Jacobian method could estimate Claude's response to mutation effects and test whether the model truly understands long-range contacts.

Related event: Researcher tests whether Claude Fable can predict protein contact maps from sequence alone(12 posts)→

Original post →

More from Research

Research channel →