HN: AI reviews catch CPA tax errors, nearly $2,000 refund at stake

echen · x · 2026-11-18

HN discussion on "DAYJOB: Tax" is going viral: one user prepared a complicated return with Astra + Codex, then used Codex to check the accountant's final form — it was riddled with errors, and the refund was nearly $2k lower than it should have been.

Another user ran personal and business returns through Claude before signing and found "a horror show of unforgivably stupid mistakes" by their CPA, including amortizing acquired-business goodwill over 5 years instead of 15 (flagged by Claude as a CRITICAL ERROR). The CPA's excuse: he caught it but forgot to save after fixing.

Poster echen notes agents could easily save people thousands of dollars a year on taxes; the thread also flips the usual narrative — for precision tasks, humans may become the untrustworthy party.

Original post →

More from Fun

Fun channel →