Astra saturates benchmarks but disappoints in real use, pushing developers to Anthropic

torchcompiled · x · 2026-11-18

Developer knowclarified (quoted) complains that GPT 6.2 Astra saturated most benchmarks yet tested demonstrably worse than Fable and even Opus 4.5 in his own use, with Astra 6 feeling worse than 6.1 — so he cancelled his Codex subscription and went all-in on Anthropic, though he'll give the new 6.2 models a shot.

torchcompiled adds a possible explanation: the model may be genuinely strong but extremely particular about prompts or overly specialized in frontier problems — if it doesn't generalize to common use cases and has poor UX, a tool is only as good as you can reasonably control it.

Original post →

More from Models

Models channel →