ICLR reviewers debate whether peers should see each other's opinions during review

guyvdb · x · 2026-11-18

In an ICLR-related discussion, @rao2z questions the notification process: rather than emailing all reviewers when reviews are flagged, why not notify only the specific flagged ones? @guyvdb responds that as a reviewer he likes knowing what other reviewers think.

The brief exchange touches an ongoing peer-review controversy: should reviewer information stay siloed for independence, or be shared to aid calibration.

Original post →

More from Research

Research channel →