ICLR AC reports 41% of live papers in their pool flagged with suspect reviews

yoavartzi · x · 2026-11-17

Yoav Artzi, serving as an ICLR Area Chair, reports that ICLR program committees have begun attaching notes to suspect reviews. In his pool of live papers, 41% received at least one such flagged review, and quite a few papers were left with only a single review. The figure offers quantified evidence of deteriorating peer-review quality in ML conferences.

Related event: ICLR AC reports 41% of live papers in their pool flagged with suspect reviews(2 posts)→

Original post →

More from Research

Research channel →