When AI narrows choice: ChatGPT picked 2 of 31 ice cream flavors 96 times out of 100

APPSO · wechat · 2026-11-17

APPSO explores how AI is flattening human choice diversity.

Columbia professor Sandra Matz tasked ChatGPT with picking Baskin-Robbins flavors: across 100 tries it recommended only "walnut cream" and "mint chocolate chip" 96 times. Her team's research, covering 110k+ real social-media choices and a 1,000-user experiment, found AI assistance significantly reduces choice uniqueness — personalized models reduce convergence between people but further shrink each individual's own breadth.

Supporting evidence cited: a 2025 study of 2,200 college essays found humans contribute 3x more to collective diversity than GPT-4; writing variance dropped 21-50% after ChatGPT's rise; during Italy's ChatGPT ban, restaurant marketing content similarity fell while engagement rose 3.5%. Drawing on Byung-Chul Han's "The Disappearance of the Other," the piece argues this homogenization is voluntary and sleep-like — actively requesting unexpected options or skipping AI on some decisions may be the last defense of aesthetic heterogeneity.

Original post →

More from AGI Musings

AGI Musings channel →