Reddit user flags peer review inflation: likely AI-written reviews earning high scores

SillyNeuron · reddit · 2026-11-17

A Reddit user reviewing a paper found troubling quality issues: a max-confidence reviewer gave a one-line "weakness" that wasn't actually a weakness plus a high score, and another review appeared ChatGPT-generated yet still earned a decent OA rating. The author laments that careful reviews may be drowned out by inflated ones, speculating this explains the shotgun-submission strategy some authors use. The post fuels concerns about peer-review integrity and AI-generated text seeping into the review process.

Original post →

More from Research

Research channel →