Researchers debate peer review: diversity of ideas vs broken proxy signals in academia

neurocy · x · 2026-11-17

HerrDreyer argues peer review, when working decently (as in PL IMO), is our best way of ensuring diversity of ideas rather than people just following cool blogs or top-university names. ArjunGuha counters that very few US universities can evaluate a PL/SE blog post's technical depth, so departments rely on proxy signals — if flagship ACM venues stop being reliable, they'll fall back on proxies like PhDs from MIT, so the fix is to repair conferences rather than abandon them.

Related event: Scholars Debate Whether Peer Review Still Works(3 posts)→

Original post →

More from AGI Musings

AGI Musings channel →