Professor rants: peer review took a year amid "AI slop" reviews — preprint would've beaten it
RexDouglass · x · 2026-11-17
@ProfSavoie vents that his paper spent a year under review, with reviewer comments full of AI slop — moving goalposts and regurgitating limitations the authors had already listed. He argues the world would have been better served by the preprint, which could have gone through several model generations before v1 sees print, and vows never again.
He admits part of the delay was his own: it was a graduating student's final paper, so edits were slow. His advice for using AI as a reviewer: (1) time you save may cost others more, and (2) authors, with full context and expertise, are better positioned to pass their own work to AI — that's not the reviewer's special competence.
More from Research
- Must-read papers of the week: robot manipulation, agent memory, long-horizon evals — TheTuringPost · 2026-11-17
- Llama 3 8B with heavy sampling beats single-shot GPT-4o on competitive programming and formal math — agihouse_org · 2026-11-17
- UCLA and AWS paper: AI agents find math shortcuts but thinking time often cancels the gains — rohanpaul_ai · 2026-11-17
- Scientific writing LLM trained to defeat detectors: Pangram 4.1 flags it as human — alejandroll10 · 2026-11-17
- ICLR 2027 debate: researchers plead with reviewers to at least acknowledge rebuttals — IanArawjo · 2026-11-17
- DeepMind researcher's open-source COrigami pipeline auto-designs flat-foldable 3D origami — TZahavy · 2026-11-17