What status did mathematicians lose? Debate erupts over Tao's grief and AI credit politics

aashiq · x · 2026-11-17

aashiq analyzes the 'mathematicians did not ask for this' backlash: AI labs desperately wanted credit for solving these problems, and since credit must come from mathematicians, that empowers them to complain — had it been a leaked internal footnote in training, the reaction would differ. Yet Tao's grief is real; 'just status loss' feels trivializing and at least partly true. He asks: what status was actually lost? The thread spirals into a debate with georgejrjrjr about credit politics between academia and AI labs.

Related event: AI Math Proofs Spark Identity Crisis Among Mathematicians(4 posts)→

Original post →