Pedro Domingos clashes with Neel Nanda: machines don't have values, says consensus

pmddomingos · x · 2026-11-17

Veteran computer scientist Pedro Domingos quote-replied DeepMind alignment researcher Neel Nanda, who claimed "we don't know how to reliably instil values into AIs, this is the scientific consensus." Domingos fired back: the actual consensus is that machines don't have values and never will — controlling them is an engineering problem — mocking "whackos at some frontier labs" who think they speak for the scientific community. The exchange highlights the deep rift between alignment researchers and senior academics on whether AI can have values.

Related event: DeepMind researcher says reliably instilling values in AI remains unsolved; Pedro Domingos pushes back(5 posts)→

Original post →

More from AGI Musings

AGI Musings channel →