Asking ChatGPT and Claude to play NeurIPS reviewers — they reject the papers

burny_tech · x · 2026-11-17

burnytech shares a fun experiment: prompting ChatGPT and Claude to act as NeurIPS reviewers on AI papers — and watching them reject. The screenshot shows Claude thinking for 7+ minutes before recommending "Reject in its current form — 2/6, confidence 4/5," citing two consequential mathematical issues and suggesting a substantially clarified revision on the NeurIPS 2026 scale.

Original post →

More from Fun

Fun channel →