Debate: peer review is drowning in bad papers, but vetted results still matter

EarlenceF · x · 2026-11-17

Security researcher Earlence Fernandes argues in an X debate that the fundamental value of academic publishing is vetting results — the core purpose peer review served. But peer review is now inundated with bad reviewers, bad papers, and bad incentives, so the old model may no longer serve its purpose even though vetted results remain necessary.

Context: HerrDreyer argued a good conference paper is just a long blog post plus supporting evidence; Fernandes countered that the difference between conf papers and blog posts is apparent.

Related event: Security researcher argues peer review is broken, blogs may be the way out(2 posts)→

Original post →

More from AGI Musings

AGI Musings channel →