CMU paper: planning agents should show plans, not ask — acceptance jumps from 12% to 55%

rohanpaul_ai · x · 2026-11-17

A Carnegie Mellon paper formalizes the ReSHAPE task: user specifications exclude plans they'd gladly accept because people only discover trade-offs when seeing concrete options. Adding one hidden trade-off raised plan acceptance from 12% to 55% (up to 4.6×) with the same planner. Current agents like Claude Code and Gemini CLI mostly ask questions and catch at most 32% of acceptable plans; showing plans beats asking by 9.7 F1 points in travel. Agents should treat requests as hypotheses and surface options outside stated limits early.

Original post →

More from coding & agent

coding & agent channel →