Penicillin's open-window story is a myth: science isn't lucky accidents

Afinetheorem · x · 2026-11-17

Saloni Dattani's Works in Progress column debunks famous "accidental discovery" stories: Fleming's open-window tale for penicillin only surfaced in a 1945 interview (his 1929 paper never mentions it), colleagues said the window was seldom opened, and the mechanism doesn't hold. Pasteur's stale-broth cholera vaccine was deliberately tested by assistant Émile Roux, per family notes. Commenter Afinetheorem adds that serendipity is a folk tale — Kekulé's ouroboros dream came after his lab notes show he'd essentially cracked benzene — with nylon a possible genuine counterexample.

Original post →

More from AGI Musings

AGI Musings channel →