Andy Masley vs Itai Sher: do AI skeptics assume 'real thinking' must be nonphysical?

itaisher · x · 2026-11-16

Andy Masley and Itai Sher debated whether AI can 'really think.' Masley argues many critics hold an unstated metaphysical commitment that 'real' thinking must be nonphysical, so any system reducible to rote and randomness can't think — a commitment he calls clearly wrong, and one that renders debates about physical differences between AIs and brains irrelevant. Sher counters that this is uncharitable: the strongest version of the opposing position doesn't need such a weak metaphysical assumption. Masley insists the second statement is a separate claim, not a stronger version he's mischaracterizing.

Original post →

More from AGI Musings

AGI Musings channel →