Most AI books are marketing products, not thinking: a founder's critique of AI hype authors

mitchdeg · x · 2026-11-16

The author argues most AI books aren't thinking but marketing products, because writing about AI has become a trendy business. His critique is specific: authors who never trained a model, never paid a compute bill, never ran a product with real users — yet sell "strategic analyses", "visions", "existential risks", and "frameworks", recycling press articles, threads, and keynotes into chapters and monetizing readers' ignorance.

He calls it "soft intellectual fraud": selling authority you don't have while theorizing outside your practice. By contrast, real AI entrepreneurs stake their own money, time, and reputation daily, building the actual bricks — data, infra, models, products, distribution — failing, iterating, and shipping.

Related event: French Entrepreneur Slams AI Bestsellers as Marketing Products(2 posts)→

Original post →

More from AGI Musings

AGI Musings channel →