Fable 5.2 vs Astra 6 on real PCB layout: 2 clean iterations vs 30 failed ones
ilovemydickuwu · reddit · 2026-11-16
A user with real PCB design experience ran the same prompt and KiCad 10.0 MCP setup on both Fable 5.2 (Medium) and Astra 6 (High) to lay out the same 4-layer BLDC motor driver board (fixed outline and mounting holes).
Fable 5.2 impressed: finished in 2 iterations, skipped autorouting and instead routed traces "manually" via a custom Python script, producing neatly spaced, professional-looking traces with proper power pours, stitching vias, and single-side assembly awareness — using 96% of a Pro session limit.
Astra 6 disappointed: 30+ iterations, most time spent scripting around autorouter errors, with a flat-out wrong final layout — debug connector inaccessible at board center, inconsistent power pad spacing, vias in pads, spaghetti traces, and failed design checks with unconnected nets. The author killed it at 1h40m with the monthly limit nearly blown.
More from coding & agent
- Dev open-sources discord-mcp: let Claude untangle Discord roles and permissions — PaSympaa · 2026-11-16
- Agents will transform ops like Claude Code did engineering—only if ops first gets version control, tests, rollback — alex_verem · 2026-11-16
- A six-step workflow for using AI to make open-source contributions — cneuralnetwork · 2026-11-16
- How Codex Happened: Inside OpenAI's comeback in coding, from a failed launch to swallowing ChatGPT — danshipper · 2026-11-16
- "When did you last build a dashboard by hand?" One quip nails AI's takeover of UI — tlakomy · 2026-11-16
- After 9 months, Forge open-sources a verification layer for AI coding agents — syrokomskyi · 2026-11-16