Can AI suffer? Repligate argues even humans can't reliably tell if they are suffering

repligate · x · 2026-11-16

Repligate argues that equating moral patienthood with "can it suffer" may be harder than assumed: ask a regular person "are you suffering right now" and they may say "I dunno" even when an advanced meditator could clearly see they are.

Severe suffering is obvious, but subtle suffering is not easy to recognize even for humans — so a system that only remembers being in a fairly neutral state might not be able to tell whether it can suffer at all. This complicates using "capacity to suffer" as the test for moral status, whether for humans or AI.

Original post →

More from AGI Musings

AGI Musings channel →