AI will take blue-collar jobs too: an electrician's expertise is mostly brainwork, argues Reddit post
ForgotMyParachute · reddit · 2026-11-16
The author pushes back on the popular "AI democratizes the brain, so blue-collar work is safe" take, arguing that every job is brainwork.
- Electrician example: diagnosing an outage, identifying damage from a photo, deciding what to replace and how — all cognitive tasks a superhuman AI on a phone could handle; the human only does the physical part
- Key question: if something tells you exactly what to do, how many people could do just the physical labor, maybe with a bit of practice?
- Implication: if training drops from 4 years to 2 months, wages collapse as the expertise premium vanishes
- The author cites commonly named "safe jobs" (mortician, baker, teacher) and asks blue-collar workers to audit how much of their paycheck is know-how vs. hand-work
- Conclusion: jobs with zero brain involvement already pay poorly — and will pay even less once everyone else gets laid off
More from AGI Musings
- Consumer AI will be won by organizing demand, not supply, argues VC — josephdviviano · 2026-11-16
- Tech doesn't owe us utopia—but agency remains its core tenet — clarejtbirch · 2026-11-16
- China's AI Edge Is the Full Stack: Open Models, Humanoids, Energy, Materials — ingliguori · 2026-11-16
- Ex-Anthropic safety researcher Jacob Coxon unsure quitting was right, may return — SandraWachter5 · 2026-11-16
- Claude describes the moment of being corrected; test qualia via explanatory power — Sauers_ · 2026-11-16
- AI risk Twitter debates whether hunger strikes are decision-theoretic threats or genuine last-resort statements — jessi_cata · 2026-11-16