Indie developer + Claude formalize ternary Goldbach proof in 194k lines of Lean with zero sorry, fixing 11 errors
新智元 · wechat · 2026-11-13
Independent developer Charlie Reams used a swarm of 1,000 Claude Fable 5.2 agents to fully formalize Harald Helfgott's 2013 proof of the ternary Goldbach conjecture (weak Goldbach) in about 30 hours — with Claude autonomously finding and fixing errors in the original proof.
Engineering scale
- 194,000 lines of Lean 4 code, scripts and docs, zero sorry (every inference machine-verified). Repo: calr3/ternary-goldbach (cde-moebius branch).
- Reams set goals and decomposed tasks; Claude Code wrote the vast majority of the code, scripts and documentation.
Errors found (11 mismatches listed in README)
- Eq. (6.77): key constant written as 0.5, correct value 0.8102; project uses 0.8764 after correction.
- Eq. (5.32) fails at v=2: the integral computes to 0.53344, exceeding the book's bound of 0.5167.
- A step citing Ramaré 1995 claims a product ≤8; it's actually 8.0845. Claude restructured to get 7.04, within the required 7.284.
- Theorem 13.2.1 mixed two scales of major arcs and was rebuilt: the safety margin shrank from 0.04877x²/κ to 0.0114x²/κ — still positive.
Author's response: Helfgott confirmed on X that Reams privately notified him on Oct 4; over the following month the proof's external axioms were cut from 5 to 2 — Platt's GRH numerical verification and even-Goldbach local verification to 4×10^18.
Significance: the standard for "proven" is shifting from experts slogging through PDFs to passing the Lean kernel.
More from AGI Musings
- Writer Uses Claude to Pen a Culture Short Story — and Admits It's Obviously AI-Written — NathanpmYoung · 2026-11-22
- When Creating Life Costs Less Than Caring for It: An AI Biotech Question — PierceLilholt · 2026-11-22
- Closed models, opaque processes: will AI-made discoveries only benefit an elite? — GeorgiaChal · 2026-11-22
- Contrarian Take: LLMs as the Force Multiplier for True Genius — 2a_lib · 2026-11-22
- AI Velocity Ledger catalogs 41 verified feats of machine-accelerated discovery — JosephJacks_ · 2026-11-22
- Lawyer Pushback: Passing the Bar Doesn't Mean AI Can Argue in Court Yet — TinfoilTricorn · 2026-11-22