"Humanity loses control in 3-12 months" claim sparks debate over whether collective will exists
repligate · x · 2026-11-13
A debate broke out around the claim "I feel very worried that humanity might no longer be in control of our future within 3-12 months."
repligate asked what people actually mean by "humanity no longer in control" — whether they have something concrete in mind, like whether humans trying to shut down AI could actually prevent it. Reposting, SkyeSharkie pushed further: it's odd to think some concept of humanity intentionally shapes the future. There is no collective Will — collectives produce results that follow the gradients of their environments, and humanity is no more willfully in control of its future with or without AI than a storm is of the direction it blows.
A substantive philosophical argument about whether "control" is a coherent concept in AI-safety discourse.
Related event: AI Safety Researchers Clash Over 'Have We Already Lost Control'(3 posts)→
More from AGI Musings
- Meme: AGI skeptic Scott Aaronson's new position is just one long scream — peterwildeford · 2026-11-13
- Oxford/DeepMind paper surveys 8,234 workers: why basic income can't replace meaning of work — lawhsw · 2026-11-13
- The Economist: AI model revenue is in the low hundreds of billions but data centers price in trillions — asusarla · 2026-11-13
- Oxford scholar on Jensen Huang's resignation: the paradox of power — CarissaVeliz · 2026-11-13
- Kai-Fu Lee's AI job-loss prediction by end of decade leaves LBC host stunned — kaifulee · 2026-11-13
- Geoffrey Huntley's one-line thesis: tokens scale, humans don't — kieranklaassen · 2026-11-13