Fixing a phone with an AI subscription: economist says GDP loss take is broken-window fallacy
neil_chilson · x · 2026-11-03
stanislavfort shared that a rare boot bug was fixed by using his $20/month AI subscription to debug and reinstall the OS instead of paying for repair or a new phone — "using way more intelligence than usual, yet counterfactually adding less to GDP." Neil Chilson counters that this mirrors the Broken Window fallacy: with AI's help you now have a working phone AND the $200, which can be spent or invested elsewhere — a net increase in wealth. The exchange highlights how AI subscriptions substituting for market services may make GDP understate real welfare gains.
Related event: Researcher Fixes Phone with $20 AI Subscription, Sparking GDP Debate(2 posts)→
More from AGI Musings
- Putting a face on robots makes intuitions about their consciousness evaporate — siglesias · 2026-11-03
- Six years after 'where are the successful rationalists', EAs really did remake the world — AndyMasley · 2026-11-03
- Perspective is the real currency of the post-AI era, not tool overload — LadyAshBorg · 2026-11-03
- Mathematician says AI has reached 'weak AGI' in mathematics, with unprecedented speedups — Scobleizer · 2026-11-03
- Zuckerberg says Meta's Muse agent may push websites toward agent-first API pipes — GramZanber · 2026-11-03
- Asking great questions beats answering them in an AI-centric world — signulll · 2026-11-03