"The agent understood me" isn't a product requirement: put implicit decisions in the spec

shoumikgoswami · reddit · 2026-10-27

An AI product builder argues the more useful question than "can the agent build this?" is "what decisions am I leaving it to make?" Using the Elephant-Goldfish Model workflow—one agent writes a spec, fresh reviewers judge it without the original conversation—he shows how vague requirements like "keep sensitive data away from the model" hide real product decisions (speaker notes? text in images? uncertain detections? export logs?). A spec should answer these or mark them unresolved; a useful test is whether review exposes a missing decision that changes the spec, or just produces reassuring text.

Original post →

More from coding & agent

coding & agent channel →