Broken evals, not weak models: OOD decision models nearly match tuned rankers

antoine_chaffin · x · 2026-10-26

bclavie argues a recent paper actually proves the opposite of its premise: OOD weak decision models (without perplexity) perform almost as well as purposefully-tuned pointwise rankers, and only look worse because broken evals like Touché give them low scores. antoinechaffin adds that even odd reranking tasks can be solved by properly defining the similarity metric evaluated in the state — a wild property worth noting.

Original post →

More from Research

Research channel →