Twilight of the mathematicians: Noah Carl argues AI will make mathematicians obsolete first

NoahCarl90 · x · 2026-10-23

In The Critic, Noah Carl's essay "Twilight of the mathematicians" opens with Ted Kaczynski's 2004 prison reply to a high schooler: mathematics is "absolutely not" worthwhile, and mathematicians "will probably become obsolete before anyone else does, because mathematics is more amenable to computerisation." The piece argues recent AI progress is validating that prediction—and frames it as tragic: "We will no longer be masters of our own destiny. For that torch will have passed to the machines."

Related event: "The Twilight of the Mathematicians" Sparks Debate Over AI Ending Human Intellectual Creativity(5 posts)→

Original post →

More from AGI Musings

AGI Musings channel →