Follow-up on eMudhra: are 8 pre-generated, never-used surplus certs normal for a CA?

kingslyj · x · 2026-10-22

@kingslyj presses @karishnu for details on the eMudhra cert incident: eMudhra claims the keys were never used for 18+ months (some certs expire 2028-12-31). Two industry questions are raised: do CAs routinely pre-generate certs, push them into browser trust stores, and never use them (for speedy swap-out of compromised certs)? And if so, is having 8 surplus certs normal? The post adds context to karishnu's claim that eMudhra deliberately added the key-generation step.

Related event: eMudhra weak root key incident: key ceremony flaw let weak keys into browser trust stores(6 posts)→

Original post →

More from Safety

Safety channel →