Golden-age children's book art showed real anatomy; modern faces have become emojis
elijahsez · x · 2026-10-15
A widely discussed observation: illustrators of the "golden age" like Jessie Willcox Smith, Elsa Beskow and Mary Cassat drew children with faithful anatomy and natural poses, grounded in close observation and affection. Modern children's books feature joints that don't articulate and emoji-like facial expressions that ignore bone structure and fat distribution — a non-digital medium aping digital conventions.
Replyers note older works have richer texture and a "lush purposefulness"; eigenrobot agrees today's children's illustration is "uniformly slop", citing Trina Schart Hyman (Caldecott-winning Saint George and the Dragon) as a later-era master, arguing the decline is quite recent.
Related event: Debate Erupts Over Decline in Children's Book Illustration(2 posts)→