Qualia Debate: EEG-to-Text Decoding Inner Speech vs. the Unverifiable 'Your Red, My Red' Problem

turchin · x · 2026-10-13

A debate on phenomenal consciousness: one side cites neuroscience showing red triggers matching brain activity across people, arguing quale skepticism smuggles in dualism. @turchin counters that EEG-to-text systems decoding inner speech show p-consciousness is simply encoded—not metaphysically hidden—yet we still can't verify if others share the same quale.

Related event: EEG Decoding of Inner Speech Sparks Debate Over Consciousness and Qualia(2 posts)→

Original post →