SemiAnalysis: Claude Subscriptions Deliver ~5x More Token Value Than OpenAI at Same Price
dotey · x · 2026-10-07
SemiAnalysis stress-tested subscription limits across nine providers (Anthropic, OpenAI, Meta, MiniMax, Moonshot, Z.ai, Cursor, Cognition) by probing token consumption per progress-bar tick and converting to API-equivalent dollar value.
Key findings:
- Top-tier models are close: on the $200 plan, OpenAI's flagship is worth $2,897 when maxed vs $2,485 for Anthropic's; but Anthropic caps its flagship at half the quota, leaving the rest for other models.
- Mid-tier is where Claude wins big: roughly 5x OpenAI's value per plan.
- Subscriptions are only 10% of Anthropic's revenue yet may consume 40%+ of inference compute, cutting blended revenue per MW by $36M.
- Oddly, one of three identical subscriptions tested showed 20% lower limits — the oldest account.
Blogger dotey corroborates: two of his own Claude Max@20 accounts drain at very different rates, the older one wearing out much faster.
More from Venture
- Founder Warns: Bubble Burst Would Devastate AI Startups With $10M+ Seed Rounds — dr1337 · 2026-11-21
- Blame game begins over Anthropic's turbulent debut as stock slides to 5 cents above IPO price — SumitGup · 2026-11-21
- If AI is electricity, what's the refrigerator? Solo devs debate moats as models improve — Nick-OneDrop · 2026-11-21
- Doctor convinces his PhD sister over WhatsApp to quit and build small-model healthcare AI — DrDatta_AIIMS · 2026-11-21
- Polymarket opens betting on when Anthropic stock closes below its $83 IPO price — Polymarket · 2026-11-21
- Creator: virality is solved, but follower retention for new accounts is harder than ever — itsOmSarraf_ · 2026-11-21