Could a stone-gear mind be conscious? AI circles debate substrate and scale
JoshPurtell · x · 2026-10-04
JoshPurtell sparked a debate on whether consciousness depends on physical substrate: he doesn't think a paper LLM would be conscious, but is open to a stone-gear reproduction of his mind — though a stone LLM would be small while a stone human mind might be star- or galaxy-sized. He adds that almost everyone agrees a lock and key isn't conscious, yet some find suns or supernovae plausibly conscious; LLMs sit far closer to lock-and-key than supernovae on that spectrum.
Related event: Machine Consciousness Debate: Is an LLM a Book or a Star-Sized Brain?(26 posts)→
More from AGI Musings
- AI pundit mocks Europe: 'bred not to desire too much' — same arrogance as mocking SpaceX — teortaxesTex · 2026-11-19
- AI alignment debate: a dark forest scenario where superintelligences preemptively strike GPU-hoarding rivals — jessi_cata · 2026-11-19
- OpenAI and Notre Dame Law School to co-host AI-for-humanity dialogue on Dec 4 — wjscheirer · 2026-11-19
- NYT: Anthropic Shows Organizational Fractures Ahead of Historic IPO — kylekabasares · 2026-11-19
- The biggest advantage of a top lab isn't money — it's saving you years — madeofAjala · 2026-11-19
- Ex-Anthropic staffer casts superintelligence as Sauron's ring; Ladish pushes back — JeffLadish · 2026-11-19