Josh Purtell argues a stone computer emulating a brain would break our consciousness intuitions
JoshPurtell · x · 2026-10-04
An ongoing machine-consciousness debate: Josh Purtell contends that a stone computer perfectly emulating the human brain would be so enormous that intuition breaks down — much like how many people find it plausible the sun could be conscious. Analog LLMs, by contrast, would be small and feel more like the Antikythera mechanism, which is decidedly not intuitively conscious.
He then sketches a functionalist reading that matches everyday intuition: sun conscious? > analog brain conscious? >> LLMs not conscious, explaining why our intuitions differ so sharply across computing substrates.
Related event: Machine Consciousness Debate: Is an LLM a Book or a Star-Sized Brain?(26 posts)→
More from AGI Musings
- AI pundit mocks Europe: 'bred not to desire too much' — same arrogance as mocking SpaceX — teortaxesTex · 2026-11-19
- AI alignment debate: a dark forest scenario where superintelligences preemptively strike GPU-hoarding rivals — jessi_cata · 2026-11-19
- OpenAI and Notre Dame Law School to co-host AI-for-humanity dialogue on Dec 4 — wjscheirer · 2026-11-19
- NYT: Anthropic Shows Organizational Fractures Ahead of Historic IPO — kylekabasares · 2026-11-19
- The biggest advantage of a top lab isn't money — it's saving you years — madeofAjala · 2026-11-19
- Ex-Anthropic staffer casts superintelligence as Sauron's ring; Ladish pushes back — JeffLadish · 2026-11-19