Max Tegmark to Duvenaud: Humans Alone Don't Reason Well Either
ThoreG · x · 2026-10-03
Responding to David Duvenaud's point that the standard criticisms of LLM reasoning (no explicit, persistent, inspectable epistemic state; no clean separation of knowledge from its manipulation; post-hoc explanations) apply equally to humans, Max Tegmark argues:
- A person alone reasons poorly; with pencil and paper, much better; a person rigorously applying the scientific method is probably an excellent reasoner.
- The trick is not to follow your stream of consciousness but to carefully structure the process — otherwise any human falls for typical cognitive biases.
The debate turns on whether externally structured processes count as reasoning.
Related event: AlphaGo Veteran Questions LLM Reasoning, Sparking Researcher Debate(6 posts)→
More from AGI Musings
- Dev challenges "AI will solve humanity's problems": where exactly in the next 5 years? — aronchick · 2026-11-17
- Top researchers are quietly stopping paper submissions, observer notes — avt_im · 2026-11-17
- "Abundant intelligence should terrify businesses built on keeping it scarce" — _AustinCalvert_ · 2026-11-17
- 130-page paper introduces "bottleneck pressure": work AI can't do gains value as the rest speeds up — soumitrashukla9 · 2026-11-17
- AI conference authors and reviewers complain unprecedentedly about AI slop — khademinori · 2026-11-17
- Sam Altman: AI already speeds up OpenAI's research, but a self-improving button? 'Definitely not' — ChrisGPT · 2026-11-17