David Duvenaud rebuts "LLMs don't reason": all the stated reasons apply to humans too

DavidDuvenaud · x · 2026-10-03

In a MIT Tech Review piece, DeepMind's Thore Graepel argues — using AlphaGo's Move 37 as a starting point — that today's most advanced AI systems still lack something fundamental: generating longer chains of thought is not the same as reasoning.

David Duvenaud, professor at the University of Edinburgh, publicly pushed back, noting that every cited reason LLMs "don't reason" applies equally to humans: no explicit, persistent, and inspectable epistemic state; no clean separation between what a system knows and how it manipulates that knowledge; and explanations concocted after the fact. "Can I reason?" he asks. The exchange reopens the debate over what counts as reasoning in LLMs.

Related event: AlphaGo Veteran Questions LLM Reasoning, Sparking Researcher Debate(6 posts)→

Original post →

More from AGI Musings

AGI Musings channel →