"Coding is NOT solved": veteran engineer's rebuttal hits #2 on Hacker News
rseroter · x · 2026-10-02
Veteran reliability engineer Alex Ewerlöf published "Coding is NOT solved," pushing back on the narrative that "LLMs can write decent code" and engineering is now about "taste." The post reached #2 on Hacker News (473 points, 476 comments) with unusually positive feedback.
Key arguments: anyone who has run software in production at scale knows maintenance, reliability, security, and scalability — the non-functional requirements — are the majority of the cost, and cheaper creation doesn't change that. Even functional requirements aren't solved, with a Dunning-Kruger effect where those who don't read the output are most confident in it. Ewerlöf stresses he's not anti-AI — an early adopter who built his own harness and teaches these topics — but rejects the "token sellers'" narrative. Sharer rseroter disagrees with many points but calls it a reasoned, worthwhile read.
More from coding & agent
- Generic API-catalog MCP server vs one tool per job: a token-efficiency tradeoff — MandeepKaur9407 · 2026-11-16
- sessionwiki turns your past coding-agent sessions into a searchable local wiki for agents — Cold_Past7184 · 2026-11-16
- Developer hits 700+ commits/day with AI, asks how to manage parallel agent work — blixt · 2026-11-16
- Alibaba's G-CAST: governed continual self-training keeps e-commerce agents fresh in production — Yuechun Yu · 2026-11-16
- harness-evals: open-source library to compare agent versions with success-vs-cost plots — slavadubrov · 2026-11-16
- Developers poll real costs of running coding agents on remote VMs for work — radim11 · 2026-11-16