IROS Debate: Generalist Robots Nail Coarse Placement 19/20 but Fail Precision Insertion 2/20
GeorgiaChal · x · 2026-10-01
At IROS 2026, Ken Goldberg and Andrea Bajcsy moderated a generalist-vs-specialist robotics debate, opened by Matt Mason's provocation: "Should animals be humans?"
Key takeaways:
- Harry Xu (pro-generalist): "Don't build Excel. Build GPT" — since tomorrow's needs are unknown, buy generality and amortize it; notably GPT didn't replace Excel, it learned to drive it.
- Georgia Chalvatzaki decomposed "general" into 4 axes — body, scene, contact, task — arguing breadth and reliability must be measured per axis and one doesn't imply the other; "the next task is the test."
- The most honest number of the day: a general model calling robot tools scored 19/20 on coarse block placement but only 2/20 on precision insertion — coarse pick-and-place works, physical composition and precise contact don't yet.
More from Embodied
- Ant Lingbo Embodied AI Challenge crowns TARS team after 48-hour real-robot hackathon — 新智元 · 2026-11-16
- Tesla FSD fleet tops 7 billion city miles, adding ~500M in under four weeks — XFreeze · 2026-11-16
- Ropedia Releases Xperience 2: 1,500+ Scanned Real-World Scenes Paired With Egocentric Demos — liuziwei7 · 2026-11-16
- Hangzhou's Manycore Tech launches Aholo MS07 3D laser scanner with CHCNAV — teortaxesTex · 2026-11-16
- LeRobot 0.7 adds YAM, reBot B601 and Unitree G1 with NVIDIA SONIC support — mishig25 · 2026-11-16
- MathWorks open-sources a GitHub repo of robotics resources for arms, rovers and drones — lukas_m_ziegler · 2026-11-16