New evolutionary theory splits intelligence from consciousness, sparking recursive-mind rebuttal
DoctorJosh · x · 2026-09-30
- A new evolutionary theory by cognitive scientist Jeff Stibel (published Sept 1) argues intelligence and consciousness evolved for different reasons: intelligence models the world outward-facing to handle uncertainty, while consciousness's regulatory processes manage internal self-protection and competing needs — explaining why AI can be smarter than humans yet not conscious.
- Replying, DoctorJosh disagrees, framing both as a "consciousness ratchet": intelligence is avoiding pain and attaining pleasure, and greater intelligence is recursive "I know that you know that I know..." nesting from which consciousness emerges.
- The exchange crystallizes a core disagreement over whether smarter AI implies anything about consciousness.
More from AGI Musings
- Will AI ever win a Nobel? Nature examines the Nobel Turing Challenge for 2050 — neurovium · 2026-10-01
- 2011 HN Comment Predicted Memory Bandwidth, Not FLOPS, Was the Real Bottleneck for Strong AI — Darpinian · 2026-10-01
- Kerala's 'Onlooker Fees': Knowledge Workers May Charge to Watch AI Work — deepakns · 2026-10-01
- Blog essay: "I became a cognitive empty nester thanks to AI agents" — vivekhaldar · 2026-10-01
- Ethan Mollick: frontier labs can ship half-built AI products because models improvise — emollick · 2026-10-01
- Researcher Lucius Caviola Warns of Social Conflict Over Diverging Beliefs in AI Sentience — cccalum · 2026-10-01