Hands-on with Dot: smarter than Grok Bot but keeps ignoring custom skill constraints
jdjohnson · x · 2026-09-30
Developer jdjohnson shares a first-hand review of the Dot agent. He finds Dot far smarter than Grok Bot and Muse, but still clumsy: it makes mistakes and later self-corrects.
Concrete issues:
- A presentation skill he built to prevent major design changes and keep pitch decks brand-aligned didn't stop Dot from changing colors and rearranging layouts.
- Dot once recommended changing a contract clause, then reversed itself when asked, claiming the change had already been made in a previous version.
He suspects long-running threads with multiple priorities cause the confusion — he didn't see the same problems in a dedicated chief-of-staff thread — and notes Dot's Astra behaves differently (worse) than the Astra in threads.
Verdict: errors are small and catchable by human review, but they're the exact mistakes he's already eliminated in his Codex and Claude Code workflows with skills, which Dot doesn't seem to respect the same way.
Related event: OpenAI dots early reviews: standout voice, rushed execution(12 posts)→
More from coding & agent
- shadcn boosts @uisdk: one-shot UI rebuild that's instantly E2E-testable by AI — shadcn · 2026-11-16
- AI agent deletes 43,599 lines of OpenClaw test code in one PR — vincent_koc · 2026-11-16
- JPMorgan shows Jarvis, its internal agent assembly line, at Interrupt NYC — LangChain · 2026-11-16
- Dev clarifies: Apple doesn't ban feature flags, only fooling App Review — talkaboutdesign · 2026-11-16
- Antigravity Matches Claude Cowork in Tests, While Gemini Tasks' Purpose Remains Unclear — sebajun2 · 2026-11-16
- One 16GB GPU runs songs, voice, images, 720p video and local RAG — all offline and open source — llama-of-death · 2026-11-16